Vivia (review below) is right, MMT is right up there with Suspense, thought much less well known.
This is a good show, with excellent production values (acting, pace, script and music) that makes for fine listening to fall asleep to each evening. Chilling? Sure, hopefully.
A show I suggest is #38. Night must Fall. It's a classic tale by Emlyn Williams, was a movie, (Rosalind Russell and Robert Montgomery - Night Must Fall (1937), and there were three other OTR productions listed on the WIKI for the original, including Suspense, but I've not gone to find them just yet.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_Must_Fall
Elsewhere I read Roc Rogers was Geoffrey Barnes.